Top News, Articles, and Interviews in Philosophy

Existence, Mathematical Nominalism, and Meta-Ontology: An Objection to Azzouni on Criteria for Existence†

Philosophy News image
AbstractJody Azzouni argues that whilst it is indeterminate what the criteria for existence are, there is a criterion that has been collectively adopted to use ‘exist’ that we can employ to argue for positions in ontology. I raise and defend a novel objection to Azzouni: his view has the counterintuitive consequence that the facts regarding what exists can and will change when users of the word ‘exist’ change what criteria they associate with its usage. Considering three responses, I argue Azzouni has best reason to take one that ultimately renders unsuccessful his arguments against mathematical abstracta.

Continue reading . . .

News source: Philosophia Mathematica Current Issue

blog comments powered by Disqus