Question about Religion - Jonathan Westphal responds

Hello philosophers , recently in a debate with Christians , I made a point that if one claims a relationship with a God or being that can't be seen , heard or touched that they are suffering from a
Philosophy News image
Hello philosophers , recently in a debate with Christians , I made a point that if one claims a relationship with a God or being that can't be seen , heard or touched that they are suffering from a delusion; is this an unfair statement and if so why ? Response from: Jonathan Westphal Unfair is a bit strong. But is it a good argument? Is your premise true?Your Christian friends could have replied that when they think about the number three, say, or any other abstract entity, they have a relationship with it.Yet one cannot see, hear, or touch such a thing. Nor does the other entity have to be abstract. One could reasonably claim to have in a conversation a relationship with another mind, but minds, even though they are concrete, "can't be seen, heard or touched", and people who make such claims are not suffering from a delusion.

Continue reading . . .

News source: AskPhilosophers.org | "All"

blog comments powered by Disqus