Question about Rationality, Religion - Stephen Maitzen responds

Is it right to call a believer rational even if she cannot prove articulately or give good arguments for her belief in God? Let's just say I ask a believer "Why do you believe in God?" and she
Philosophy News image
Is it right to call a believer rational even if she cannot prove articulately or give good arguments for her belief in God? Let's just say I ask a believer "Why do you believe in God?" and she simply answered, "Because I've experienced God's grace in my life," and she needs no arguments or other evidences for her belief, is her position justifiable? I personally thinks it is but if that is the case, then what would make belief in God irrational, if simply certain personal experiences can justify such belief? Response from: Stephen Maitzen If she had reasons to believe, it would not be faith that she had but knowledge.I respectfully reject the implicit reasoning in Prof. Marino's claim. Someone's having reasons to believe may make her belief rational or epistemically justified, but her belief is knowledge only if her belief is true, and its truth doesn't follow from her having reasons to believe.[A]s human beings we still have to decide whether or not [to] believe in what falls. . .

Continue reading . . .

News source: AskPhilosophers.org | "All"

blog comments powered by Disqus